메뉴 건너뛰기

군사국방

국방뉴스

[ISW] 러시아의 공세 캠페인 평가, 2024년 11월 18일

by Summa posted Nov 19, 2024
?

단축키

Prev이전 문서

Next다음 문서

ESC닫기

크게 작게 위로 아래로 댓글로 가기 인쇄
?

단축키

Prev이전 문서

Next다음 문서

ESC닫기

크게 작게 위로 아래로 댓글로 가기 인쇄

```html Key Takeaways: 요약

요약

  • 러시아 관리들은 미국이 쿠르스크 주에 있는 러시아와 북한 군사 목표에 대한 우크라이나의 ATACMS 사용을 공개적으로 승인하지 못하도록 억제하기 위한 노력의 일환으로 위협적인 수사를 계속 사용했습니다. 이러한 미국의 승인은 공식적으로 확인된다면, 러시아가 우크라이나 침공에서 북한군을 적극적인 전투원으로 투입한 것에 대한 온건한 대응이 될 것입니다.
  • 푸틴이 우크라이나 침공에서 북한을 새로운 교전국으로 도입한 것은 중대한 확대였습니다. 우크라이나가 모든 국제법과 무력 분쟁법에 따라 러시아 영토 내 합법적인 군사 목표에 미사일을 사용하도록 허용하는 것은 매우 제한적인 대응이며, 그 자체로 확대라고 합리적으로 특징지을 수 없습니다.
  • 프랑스와 영국의 소식통은 11월 18일에 우크라이나가 러시아 내에서 제한된 공격에 ATACMS를 사용할 수 있다는 미국의 허가는 본질적으로 우크라이나가 프랑스와 영국에서 제공한 SCALP 및 Storm Shadow 미사일을 러시아에서 장거리 공격에 사용할 수 있는 능력으로 확장되지 않는다고 밝혔습니다.
  • 크렘린은 현재 전선을 따라 갈등을 "동결"시키는 것을 포함한 모든 타협을 받아들이지 않겠다는 의지를 계속 표명하고 있습니다. 이는 크렘린이 우크라이나의 완전한 항복을 고집하고 있음을 더욱 잘 보여줍니다.
  • 러시아군은 최근 쿠르스크 주의 주요 우크라이나 돌출부인 쿠먁얀스크, 크레민나 서쪽, 시베르스크, 포크롭스크, 부흘레다르 방향으로 진격했습니다.
  • 크렘린은 러시아의 전면적 우크라이나 침공 참전 용사들을 지방, 지역 및 연방 정부의 직책에 배치하는 것을 목표로 하는 "영웅의 시간" 프로그램을 확대하여 러시아 정부의 여러 계층을 계속 군사화하고 있습니다.
  • 러시아 국방부(MoD)는 러시아의 2024년 가을 징집 주기의 일환으로 점령된 도네츠크, 루한스크, 헤르손, 자포리지아 주에서 우크라이나 청소년을 불법으로 징집했습니다.

분류: 군사, 정치 관련된 주요국가: 러시아, 우크라이나, 북한 향후 전망: 러시아는 우크라이나에서의 군사적 우위를 확보하기 위해 계속 노력할 것이며, 우크라이나는 미국과 유럽 연합의 지원을 받아 저항을 계속할 것입니다.
```

[원문]

ISW Logo

Russian Offensive Campaign Assessment

Support ISW

Christina Harward, Karolina Hird, Davit Gasparyan, Kateryna Stepanenko, Nicole Wolkov, Nate Trotter, William Runkel, Olivia Gibson, and Frederick W. Kagan


November 18, 2024, 5:30pm ET

Click here to view our Russia-Ukraine interactive maps.


Click here to view our special reports since 2024.

Russian officials continued to use threatening rhetoric as part of efforts to deter the United States from publicly authorizing Ukraine's use of US-provided ATACMS in limited strikes against Russian and North Korean military targets in Kursk Oblast. This US authorization, if officially confirmed, would notably be a mild response to Russia's escalatory introduction of North Korean troops as active combatants in Russia's invasion of Ukraine. Kremlin Spokesperson Dmitry Peskov claimed on November 18 that the United States is "adding fuel to the fire" and that the US authorization of Ukrainian ATACMS strikes against Russian military targets would be a "qualitatively new round of tension" and a "qualitative" change in US participation in the war. Peskov reiterated Russian President Vladimir Putin's September 12 claims that Ukrainian strikes against Russia using Western-provided weapons would represent an escalation and directly involve Western countries in the war. Russian Ministry of Foreign Affairs (MFA) Spokesperson Maria Zakharova also reiterated Putin's September statements and further claimed that Ukrainian long-range missile strikes on Russia would be a "radical change in the essence and nature" of the war and that the Russian response would be "adequate and tangible." Russian State Duma and Federation Council deputies made similar threats, claiming that Russia would be "forced" to respond to this "escalation," including with strikes against Ukraine using unspecified "new" weapons systems, and that Russia's new nuclear doctrine will outline the consequences of this US decision. Russia has not previously escalated militarily against any perceived Western violations of Russia's "red lines" — as ISW has repeatedly observed.


Select Russian officials and propagandists heavily emphasized that US officials have not yet formally confirmed the ATACMS strike authorization, likely in an attempt to convince the United States to back out of the decision and deny the media reports of the authorization. Zakharova stated that it is unclear if Western media outlets reporting on the US authorization are citing official sources, and Russian propagandist Vladimir Solovyov similarly questioned the credibility of the US media reports.


Neither Ukrainian nor US officials have confirmed reports of the US authorization of Ukrainian ATACMS strikes, but US officials noted that Russia escalated the war with the deployment of North Korean forces alongside Russian forces on the battlefield. Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky did not directly confirm media reports of the US authorization of limited ATACMS strikes, but stated on November 17 that "strikes are not carried out with words" and "such things are not announced," but that "the missiles will speak for themselves." US Deputy National Security Advisor Jonathan Finer also did not confirm the US strike authorization but noted that Russia escalated the war with the deployment of North Korean forces to the battlefield and the massive drone and missile strike series against Ukrainian energy infrastructure on the night of November 16 to 17. Finer directly responded to Peskov, stating that Russia's full-scale invasion of Ukraine "lit the fire." US outlet Axios reported on November 17 that a source with knowledge of the matter stated that the Biden administration granted Ukraine permission to use ATACMS in order to deter North Korea from sending more troops to Russia for the war. Axios reported that US officials hope that North Korea might reconsider its decision to deploy military personnel to Russia if Ukrainian forces strike North Korean forces in Kursk Oblast.


Key Takeaways:


  • Russian officials continued to use threatening rhetoric as part of efforts to deter the United States from publicly authorizing Ukraine's use of US-provided ATACMS in limited strikes against Russian and North Korean military targets in Kursk Oblast. This US authorization, if officially confirmed, would notably be a mild response to Russia's escalatory introduction of North Korean troops as active combatants in Russia's invasion of Ukraine.


  • Putin's introduction of North Korea as a new belligerent in his invasion of Ukraine was a major escalation. Allowing Ukraine to use US missiles against legitimate military targets in Russian territory in accord with all international laws and laws of armed conflict is a very limited response and cannot reasonably be characterized as an escalation in itself.


  • French and British sources clarified on November 18 that the reported US permissions regarding Ukraine's ability to use ATACMS for limited strikes within Russia do not inherently extend to Ukraine's ability to use French and UK-provided SCALP and Storm Shadow missiles for long-range strikes in Russia.


  • The Kremlin continues to state its unwillingness to accept any compromises, including those that would "freeze" the conflict along the current frontline – further demonstrating the Kremlin's insistence on complete Ukraine capitulation.


  • Russian forces recently advanced in the main Ukrainian salient in Kursk Oblast, in Kupyansk, west of Kreminna, and in the Siversk, Pokrovsk, and Vuhledar directions.


  • The Kremlin is continuing to militarize different levels of the Russian government by expanding the "Time of Heroes" program that aims to place veterans of the Russian full-scale invasion of Ukraine in positions in local, regional, and federal governments.


  • The Russian Ministry of Defense (MoD) illegally conscripted Ukrainian youth in occupied Donetsk, Luhansk, Kherson, and Zaporizhia oblasts as part of Russia's Fall 2024 conscription cycle.


Click Here to Read the Full Report

Interactive Map of Hundreds of Known Russian Military Objects in Range of ATACMS

Click here to read the major report from Drs. Kimberly and Frederick W. Kagan, "Ukraine and the Problem of Restoring Maneuver in Contemporary War."

Website | Jobs & Internships


Follow ISW on social media:


Facebook | X | YouTube | Instagram | LinkedIn | Threads | Bluesky

Donate online or by sending a check to the Institute for the Study of War at 1400 16th Street NW, Suite #515, Washington, DC, 20036. Please consider including the Institute for the Study of War in your estate plans.


ISW is a tax-exempt organization under section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code. Donations are tax-deductible to the extent permitted by law.

The Institute for the Study of War (ISW) is a non-partisan, non-profit, public policy research organization. ISW advances an informed understanding of military affairs through reliable research, trusted analysis, and innovative education. We are committed to improving the nation's ability to execute military operations and respond to emerging threats in order to achieve US strategic objectives.



위로